Grab a cold brew and wander past open-air stalls scattered across a sprawling, tree-shaded lawn to pick up fresh Peconic Bay oysters, organic greens, and wild cut flowers straight from local island growers. 8

Grab a kayak and slurp ice-cold, briny bivalves right out of the floating mesh cages anchored in the North Fork's salty tidal currents. 8.5

This Southold shop keeps its coolers packed with live sandworms and fresh bunker to get anglers rigged for fluke and stripers in the Peconic Bay. 8

Right off the harbor walking trail, local smiths hammer red-hot iron over open coal fires, slinging bright sparks into the fresh bay breeze. 7.5

Grab the reins to steer gentle horses along dirt paths through coastal oak woods just minutes from the ocean. 8